Birdlady:

You said DMSA didn't work for you and you are no better.

Well DMSA isn't an essential chelation agent for the AC protocol. ALA is what takes the mercury out. DMSA just surpresses symptoms.

DMSA or DMPS don't get into your brain or other organs. They just detox your blood. ALA does the real detox work. So its not a surprise that DMSA chelation did not help you.

You said Cutler or FCD is against DMPS.

Cutler says DMPS is more effective than DMSA and he prefers it but he feels the cost is too high for many. The moderator of FCD Lindajaytee chelated for a lonhg time with DMPS. So did other moderators.
They are not against DMPS.

You said the studies the work of andy cutler is based on are not available or in russian language

well that's not true. There has been a translation of the russian posted on one of the chelation listserver. It has been there for almost 10 years.

Also you suggested that DMPS will cure people and other aganets will not.

The problem is that DMPS does not access brain tissue. It will not detox your nervous system. The only thing that can do that is ALA.

You said that studies show that ALA will redistribute mercury to mother places.

Yes but this is why andy cutler says you have to take it every 3 hours or you will redistribute mercury to more sensitive locations.

You said that there are only success stories with DMPS but not with the cutler protocol and Sunshine isn't a real sucess story.


According to your strict criteria the mercurylife.com story isn't a real success story either since the person clearly states the he is not OK and still in the chelation process.

Generally there is a lack of chelation success stories not matter what method you look at.

But there are success stories with the cutler protocol.

have a look here:

http://whatidontknow.net/blog/eight-years-and-counting-my-chelation-story/

or here:

This is a progress report. 5 years later the person claims to be completely cured. (see the robert cartland story in the second link)


http://onibasu.com/archives/am/84889.html
http://onibasu.com/wiki/Progress_reports


or here:

here is an interview with Dr. Pompa and andy cutler. Dr. Pompa claims that he was very sick from mercury poisoning and chelated himself with the cutler protocol and is well now.

http://www.healthcentersofthefuture.com/DrCutler/


I know a few others but i am too lazy to list them.

You said the Amy Holmes study showed that the cutler protocol worked only for the very young children but the 18 year old did not show any improvement

Cutler said that very young children will often respond within a few rounds but for adults it will take 10-12 round to notice significant improvements.

To my best knowledge the children in the study were only chelated for 8 rounds which isn't really much. I think it would be a bit premature to say it didn't work for 18 year olds since you would only expect the very young to improve significanty with such a small number of rounds.

I can understand your frustration about the lack of success stories and skepticism about AC but i think your are missing the point when you say DMSA is not effective but DMPSA is.

Both are ineffective in the sense that they will not detox for poisoned organs including your brain.

The question is if ALA is effective not if DMPS is better than DMSA. You also made some comments about the cutler protocol which are just not true.