Bex, I clicked on one of RAZD's links, which includes pictures from the book. You can see the lure with the hook for yourself. Would you and CTD be defending a book with this in it? Should people be learning science from it? No this is not the only argument I'd make in reply to what's been posted here, but I have little time to type any kind of detailed response and the fishing lure kind of stood out.

Apparently Yahya took pictures of fishing lures from the website of realistic fishing lure creator Graham Owen. If you don't want to hear it from Dawkins' site, then read here.

This is really funny actually, and it's funny watching people trying to defend it. Sorry but this really is the height of absurdity.