|
|
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 1,977
Master Elite Member
|
My, don't you just shun that burden of proof! The abiogenesis crowd is making the crazy claim that life arose from a random natural process. They up & made that claim after it was well known that life does not arise from non-life. Now they'd made it in the past & got slam-dunked, but they didn't learn their lesson. This time, they need to produce.
Now chemistry ain't my bag. It's fascinating, but too much memorization. And I'm confident they already know most of the ways atoms bond, and the limitations. Bonds are bonds, after all. Things that are bound can't up & do as they please. I'd say those bonds are probably the very mechanism you're asking me to provide, but I'd have to investigate some more before I could be firm about it.
And besides, if nature could manufacture anything better in the way of complexity, why are you guys always bringing up snow? This is largely an argument from incredulity. Saying that you don't believe something is possible does not mean that it isn't. History is replete with examples of the seemingly-impossible becoming mainstream knowledge. Ain't quantum mechanics just zany stuff? If chemistry ain't your bag, then why are you essentially accusing the majority of chemists of being liars, or not knowing what they are talking about? What qualifies you to do this? Mix some organic chemicals with the snow, subject the lot to the conditions that existed on the early earth, leave it for millions of years, and who knows what might happen? As far as burden of proof goes, then it's entirely possible to test how a theory might not be true. Are you able to do this regarding abiogenesis, or otherwise come up with some proof that it is impossible? If not, then the matter reamins unresolved and in need of further study.
|
|
|
|
Entire Thread
|
What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
Russ
|
12/14/07 01:25 AM
|
Re: Yes, What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
RAZD
|
12/15/07 03:51 PM
|
Re: Yes, What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
Kitsune
|
12/15/07 05:53 PM
|
Re: Yes, What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
RAZD
|
12/15/07 06:25 PM
|
Re: Yes, What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
Kitsune
|
12/15/07 09:00 PM
|
Re: Yes, What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
RAZD
|
12/15/07 10:38 PM
|
Re: Yes, What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
Kitsune
|
12/15/07 11:03 PM
|
Honesty Is the Best Policy
|
Russ
|
12/21/07 05:54 PM
|
Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
RAZD
|
12/21/07 07:03 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
SoSick
|
12/21/07 09:07 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
Pwcca
|
12/21/07 10:47 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
SoSick
|
12/21/07 11:00 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
Pwcca
|
12/21/07 11:09 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
SoSick
|
12/21/07 11:15 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
Pwcca
|
12/21/07 11:58 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
SoSick
|
12/22/07 12:03 AM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
SoSick
|
12/22/07 06:01 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
Pwcca
|
12/22/07 10:35 PM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach.
|
SoSick
|
12/23/07 03:31 AM
|
Re: Dealing with reality, a soup to nuts approach: What's LIFE?
|
RAZD
|
01/06/08 09:29 PM
|
Pssst: The masses are catching on.
|
Russ
|
01/21/08 02:01 AM
|
Re: Pssst: The masses are catching on.
|
LinearAq
|
03/14/08 05:24 PM
|
Trolling Warning
|
Russ
|
03/14/08 09:09 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning
|
LinearAq
|
03/14/08 09:35 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning
|
SoSick
|
03/15/08 03:13 AM
|
Re: Trolling Warning
|
Kitsune
|
03/15/08 12:31 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning
|
SoSick
|
03/15/08 05:14 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning
|
Kitsune
|
03/15/08 05:52 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning
|
Kitsune
|
03/15/08 06:00 PM
|
Trolling Warning: Thin Ice Ahead
|
Russ
|
03/16/08 01:01 AM
|
Re: Trolling Warning: Thin Ice Ahead
|
Kitsune
|
03/16/08 07:39 AM
|
Re: Trolling Warning: Thin Ice Ahead
|
Laura Clement
|
03/16/08 07:36 PM
|
More quotes from Linda
|
Bex
|
03/17/08 05:07 AM
|
Re: More quotes from Linda
|
Bex
|
03/17/08 07:26 AM
|
Re: More quotes from Linda
|
Pwcca
|
03/17/08 07:52 AM
|
Re: More quotes from Linda
|
Bex
|
03/17/08 10:59 AM
|
Re: More quotes from Linda
|
Kitsune
|
03/17/08 09:52 PM
|
Re: More quotes from Linda
|
Bex
|
03/18/08 01:31 AM
|
Re: More quotes from Linda
|
Kitsune
|
03/18/08 07:56 AM
|
Re: More quotes from Linda
|
Bex
|
03/18/08 09:50 AM
|
Re: More quotes from Linda
|
SoSick
|
03/18/08 04:12 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning: Thin Ice Ahead
|
Kitsune
|
03/17/08 07:15 AM
|
Re: Trolling Warning: Thin Ice Ahead
|
SomedaySoon
|
03/17/08 02:32 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning: Thin Ice Ahead
|
Kitsune
|
03/17/08 10:25 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning: Thin Ice Ahead
|
SomedaySoon
|
03/17/08 11:55 PM
|
Re: Trolling Warning: Thin Ice Ahead
|
Kitsune
|
03/18/08 07:25 AM
|
Re: Pssst: The masses are catching on.
|
Bex
|
03/17/08 11:32 AM
|
Forward to the subject
|
LinearAq
|
03/17/08 01:57 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Bex
|
03/18/08 12:12 AM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Kitsune
|
03/18/08 05:56 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
SoSick
|
03/18/08 06:07 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Kitsune
|
03/18/08 06:13 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
SoSick
|
03/18/08 06:23 PM
|
Disconnnected?
|
CTD
|
03/18/08 08:18 PM
|
Evospeak
|
CTD
|
03/18/08 08:53 PM
|
Re: Evospeak
|
LinearAq
|
03/18/08 09:11 PM
|
Re: Evospeak
|
Kitsune
|
03/18/08 09:24 PM
|
Re: Evospeak
|
CTD
|
03/19/08 07:49 AM
|
Re: Evospeak
|
LinearAq
|
03/19/08 04:16 PM
|
No snowjob
|
CTD
|
03/19/08 07:57 PM
|
Re: No snowjob
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 09:12 PM
|
Re: No snowjob
|
CTD
|
03/19/08 10:31 PM
|
Re: No snowjob
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 03:24 PM
|
Re: No snowjob
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 07:32 PM
|
Re: No snowjob
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 09:28 PM
|
More
|
CTD
|
03/21/08 01:34 AM
|
Re: More
|
Kitsune
|
03/21/08 08:15 AM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
03/21/08 11:57 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
03/24/08 01:20 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/07/09 07:39 AM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/07/09 01:47 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/07/09 07:01 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/07/09 09:04 PM
|
Re: More
|
Russ
|
01/07/09 10:58 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/08/09 04:16 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/08/09 05:14 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/08/09 06:02 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/08/09 06:59 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/08/09 07:20 PM
|
Re: More
|
Russ
|
01/08/09 10:46 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/09/09 02:52 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/09/09 07:28 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/09/09 08:00 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/09/09 09:36 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/11/09 03:31 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/12/09 05:20 AM
|
Rules, Rules, Rules
|
Russ
|
01/12/09 07:40 AM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/12/09 12:21 PM
|
Re: More
|
Russ
|
01/12/09 11:50 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/13/09 02:19 PM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/13/09 07:21 PM
|
Re: More
|
Mordecai
|
01/13/09 08:08 PM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/13/09 09:16 PM
|
Re: More
|
Lynnmn
|
01/14/09 01:37 AM
|
Re: More
|
Russ
|
01/14/09 06:47 AM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/14/09 03:28 PM
|
An Affront to Science
|
Russ
|
01/14/09 10:06 PM
|
Re: An Affront to Science
|
LinearAq
|
01/15/09 01:11 PM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/14/09 06:51 AM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/14/09 09:04 AM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/14/09 03:16 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/15/09 10:46 AM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/15/09 04:10 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/15/09 05:54 PM
|
Re: More
|
Abigail
|
01/15/09 08:20 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/15/09 08:58 PM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/16/09 11:59 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/20/09 01:56 PM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/20/09 09:46 PM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/21/09 03:30 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/21/09 11:12 PM
|
Mob Mentality
|
Russ
|
01/22/09 12:02 AM
|
Re: Mob Mentality
|
LinearAq
|
01/22/09 02:38 PM
|
Re: Mob Mentality
|
Russ
|
01/23/09 03:41 PM
|
Re: Mob Mentality
|
LinearAq
|
01/23/09 04:35 PM
|
How Reliable
|
Russ
|
01/23/09 10:02 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
LinearAq
|
01/26/09 03:58 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
Russ
|
01/29/09 12:00 AM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
LinearAq
|
01/29/09 01:35 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
Russ
|
01/29/09 10:53 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
LinearAq
|
02/02/09 12:34 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
Russ
|
02/03/09 07:07 AM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
LinearAq
|
02/03/09 04:13 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
Russ
|
02/04/09 04:51 AM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
LinearAq
|
02/05/09 12:34 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
Russ
|
02/05/09 10:00 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
LinearAq
|
02/06/09 03:56 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
Russ
|
02/06/09 09:50 PM
|
Re: How Reliable
|
LinearAq
|
02/09/09 01:14 PM
|
What Was The Question Again?
|
Russ
|
02/10/09 08:07 AM
|
Re: What Was The Question Again?
|
LinearAq
|
02/10/09 01:12 PM
|
Re: What Was The Question Again?
|
Russ
|
02/11/09 01:37 AM
|
Re: What Was The Question Again?
|
LinearAq
|
02/11/09 06:58 PM
|
Re: What Was The Question Again?
|
Kitsune
|
02/11/09 07:22 PM
|
Re: What Was The Question Again?
|
Russ
|
02/12/09 02:02 AM
|
Re: What Was The Question Again?
|
Russ
|
03/24/09 07:19 AM
|
Re: What Was The Question Again?
|
Russ
|
03/24/09 07:20 AM
|
The more we discover....
|
CTD
|
04/08/09 10:54 PM
|
Re: What Was The Question Again?
|
Russ
|
02/12/09 01:51 AM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/22/09 02:21 PM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/24/09 03:57 AM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/24/09 06:48 AM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/24/09 07:41 AM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/24/09 03:08 PM
|
Misunderstanding
|
LinearAq
|
01/26/09 03:27 PM
|
Re: Misunderstanding
|
Bex
|
01/31/09 06:05 AM
|
Re: Misunderstanding
|
LinearAq
|
02/02/09 05:32 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/15/09 09:10 PM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/17/09 03:31 AM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/15/09 08:50 PM
|
Re: More
|
Bex
|
01/15/09 12:22 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/15/09 01:09 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/15/09 01:50 PM
|
Re: More
|
CTD
|
01/20/09 07:21 AM
|
Re: More
|
LinearAq
|
01/20/09 02:02 PM
|
Re: No snowjob
|
LinearAq
|
03/20/08 12:56 PM
|
Re: No snowjob
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 07:06 PM
|
Re: No snowjob
|
LinearAq
|
03/21/08 12:39 PM
|
Good Friday ----- Sunday
|
LinearAq
|
03/21/08 08:48 PM
|
Re: Good Friday ----- Sunday
|
Bex
|
03/21/08 10:38 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/18/08 09:07 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
CTD
|
03/19/08 11:45 AM
|
Quote Mining Yet Again
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 02:17 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 02:50 PM
|
Horsefeathers
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 04:19 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
CTD
|
03/19/08 06:11 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
SoSick
|
03/19/08 06:43 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
SoSick
|
03/19/08 06:55 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 12:03 AM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
SoSick
|
03/20/08 01:48 AM
|
RE: Disconnection and brainwash
|
SoSick
|
03/20/08 03:10 AM
|
Re: RE: Disconnection and brainwash
|
SoSick
|
03/20/08 05:21 AM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 07:04 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
SoSick
|
03/19/08 07:17 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 07:38 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
CTD
|
03/19/08 09:23 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 09:56 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
LinearAq
|
03/19/08 07:54 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
SoSick
|
03/19/08 08:23 PM
|
Evidence
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 09:03 PM
|
Re: Evidence
|
SoSick
|
03/19/08 09:17 PM
|
Re: Evidence
|
LinearAq
|
03/20/08 02:46 PM
|
Re: Evidence
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 04:28 PM
|
Re: Evidence
|
CTD
|
03/19/08 11:27 PM
|
Re: Evidence
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 04:00 PM
|
Re: Evidence
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 10:04 PM
|
Re: Evidence
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 11:00 PM
|
Re: Evidence
|
CTD
|
03/21/08 05:46 AM
|
Re: Evidence
|
Kitsune
|
03/21/08 08:57 AM
|
Re: Evidence
|
CTD
|
03/22/08 01:09 AM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
LinearAq
|
03/20/08 12:25 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
CTD
|
03/19/08 08:58 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 09:54 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 01:45 AM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 07:15 AM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 04:26 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 08:29 PM
|
Re: Disconnnected?
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 09:48 PM
|
Doubletalkin' Dicky-D
|
CTD
|
04/28/08 07:06 AM
|
A simple video of prebiotic mechanisms
|
RAZD
|
07/14/08 01:20 AM
|
My boo-boo
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 02:02 PM
|
Religious freedom must be maintained.
|
LinearAq
|
03/18/08 09:01 PM
|
Re: Religious freedom must be maintained.
|
SoSick
|
03/18/08 11:46 PM
|
Re: Religious freedom must be maintained.
|
LinearAq
|
03/19/08 04:31 PM
|
Re: Religious freedom must be maintained.
|
SoSick
|
03/19/08 05:13 PM
|
Re: Religious freedom must be maintained.
|
LinearAq
|
03/19/08 06:06 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
LinearAq
|
03/18/08 07:51 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Bex
|
03/18/08 08:16 AM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Kitsune
|
03/18/08 05:06 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
SoSick
|
03/18/08 05:43 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Kitsune
|
03/18/08 06:12 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Bex
|
03/19/08 07:06 AM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Kitsune
|
03/19/08 02:37 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
LinearAq
|
03/18/08 08:16 PM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
Bex
|
03/19/08 08:29 AM
|
Re: Forward to the subject
|
LinearAq
|
03/19/08 05:57 PM
|
Russ posts replies on other threads?
|
RAZD
|
01/19/08 11:31 PM
|
Re: Honesty Is the Best Policy
|
CTD
|
03/16/08 10:14 AM
|
Abiogenesis
|
Kitsune
|
03/16/08 12:51 PM
|
Re: Abiogenesis
|
CTD
|
03/17/08 10:07 AM
|
abiogenesis science?
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 03:17 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
Kitsune
|
03/20/08 04:38 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
LinearAq
|
03/20/08 04:57 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
CTD
|
03/20/08 09:59 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
LinearAq
|
03/21/08 11:37 AM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
CTD
|
03/21/08 08:55 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
LinearAq
|
03/21/08 09:39 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
CTD
|
03/22/08 04:05 AM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
Kitsune
|
03/22/08 07:32 AM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
LinearAq
|
03/22/08 01:47 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
CTD
|
03/22/08 08:15 PM
|
history coverup
|
SoSick
|
03/23/08 05:34 AM
|
Re: history coverup
|
CTD
|
03/23/08 12:20 PM
|
Re: history coverup
|
SoSick
|
03/23/08 03:24 PM
|
Re: history coverup
|
Kitsune
|
03/24/08 07:19 AM
|
Re: history coverup
|
CTD
|
03/24/08 09:50 AM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
LinearAq
|
03/25/08 03:55 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
CTD
|
03/25/08 05:09 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
LinearAq
|
03/25/08 08:40 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
CTD
|
03/26/08 06:49 AM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
Kitsune
|
03/26/08 08:11 AM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
LinearAq
|
03/26/08 01:39 PM
|
Re: abiogenesis science?
|
CTD
|
03/27/08 06:47 AM
|
More nails for coffins
|
CTD
|
04/16/08 01:57 AM
|
I got dibs!
|
CTD
|
04/22/08 04:11 AM
|
Re: What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
CTD
|
02/01/09 07:50 AM
|
Re: What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
CTD
|
09/02/09 08:44 AM
|
Re: What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
CTD
|
01/09/10 01:38 AM
|
Re: What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
CTD
|
03/10/10 06:03 AM
|
Re: What Exacty is Abiogenesis?
|
CTD
|
04/26/11 04:36 AM
|
|
|
|